Listen on:

Iran vs. the West, Again

Guest: Vali Nasr, former Dean of The Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies and a renowned expert on the Middle East and Shia Islam

Iran is again giving the West a headache. Its resurgent nuclear development, the recent trade pact with China, the dangerous rivalry with Saudi Arabia, and near-boil tensions with Israel catapult Iran again to the top of the world’s security risks. All this is background to new nuclear talks in Vienna between the new Biden Administration and Iran’s hardline government.  

Vali Nasr, former dean of The Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies and Economist-described “leading world authority on Shia Islam,” joins hosts Peter Schechter and Muni Jensen on Altamar’s latest podcast episode to discuss Iran’s rapidly changing dynamics. Nasr is a well-known Iranian American academic who has served as a Senior Advisor to the US government and is the author of The Dispensable Nation and other books on the Middle East.

In 2015, Iran and the P5+1 (US, UK, France, Germany, Russia, and China) brokered a deal known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) to achieve nuclear de-escalation. In return for pausing Iran’s nuclear ambitions, the West lifted its strangling economic sanctions. But in 2017, the Trump administration abruptly pulled out of the deal, and Iran retaliated by resuming its nuclear program.

Tensions are swirling again. In early April, an explosion at Iran’s Natanz nuclear facility was linked to Israeli subversion. This was the backdrop when JCPOA talks reconvened in Vienna and the outcome of the talks is hard to predict. What happens next? Is denuclearization in Iran possible? Will the U.S. and Iran return to the agreement with full compliance? 

The backdrop of the Vienna nuclear talks is less than ideal. The region has changed, and the political atmosphere is now different– both in Iran and in the United States. “It’s much more difficult to cut a deal not only because of the hardened politics, but also because Russia and China have really expanded their influence,” notes Altamar’s Muni Jensen.

America’s pullout from the JCPOA in 2017 created a lot of resentment in Iran. “Iranians believed that all Trump era sanctions were put on Iran in bad faith. Iran was in full compliance, according to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in January 2017. And Trump moved out of the deal and put sanctions on Iran. So, Iranians now believe that full compliance with America means going back to 2017,” says Nasr. 

Nasr points out that concessions are unlikely anytime soon since Iran faces a very important presidential election in June. “More than likely, we’re going to see a more hardline Iranian candidate win the presidency and that will immediately impact the nuclear talks. A new team also means that you’re not going to be even continuing the nuclear conversation till September when they come in. And then after that, you’re going to have fresh faces who won the election on the basis of being tough with the US.,”Nasr notes. 

When it comes to the most recent, alleged attack by Israel, Nasr notes the decision to respond is a political hot potato in Iran. “Generally, the security forces and the conservatives had continuously blamed dual citizens and put the more moderate and liberal forces in prison. And yet, the most serious security breaches in Iran have happened in areas where they are responsible for security,” says Nasr. But Iran is playing the long game. I think [Iran is] going to hold off on retaliation…Because they know that the Israelis are baiting them, and that Israelis would love for Iran to do something that would shift the discussion away from the nuclear talks to Iran’s behavior and would in fact get the United States into a direct confrontation with Iran. So, they don’t want to play Israel’s game,” explains Nasr. 

Despite being one of the youngest societies in the world, young Iranians are extremely diverse. “It’s not just that the young people are all pro-Western liberal. That’s a big segment, but also most of the revolutionary guards and the thugs that they deploy in the street are also high school dropouts and young people. All put together, Iranians want a different country. They want a country that is engaged in the world, that is respected, that is doing trade and business with the world, and that domestically is much more open. And there are things that any young generation wants, which is different from the older generation…the power elite in Iran are very old. And the people that they rule across the board are very young. Iran is well set for change. We just don’t know how it’s going to happen, and in which direction.” 

Want to learn more about the future of Iran in a rapidly changing world? Find out by listening to the latest Altamar episode, available wherever you get your podcasts. You can download the episode here.

Image Source: Eblis/Getty Images


More from this show


Make sure to subscribe to our newsletter for updates about new episodes.

Follow Altamar

Episode 98